The U.S. southern border has long been a focal point of national debate, drawing intense scrutiny over issues of immigration, national security, and humanitarian concerns.

Under President Joe Biden’s administration, this debate has reached new heights, with critics arguing that leniency in border policies has led to a surge in illegal immigration, exacerbating problems related to drug trafficking, human trafficking, and violent crime in the United States.

We’ll explore the complex dynamics at play, highlighting the implications of a weak border and advocating for a nuanced approach that balances security with compassion.

The Current State of the Border

Since President Biden took office, there has been a notable increase in the number of migrants attempting to cross the U.S.-Mexico border.

The Biden administration’s policies, which emphasize a more humane approach to immigration, have been criticized by opponents who argue that they inadvertently encourage illegal crossings.

In fiscal year 2021, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) reported over 1.7 million encounters with migrants at the southern border, the highest number in decades. This surge has strained resources and raised concerns about the capacity to effectively manage and process incoming migrants.

The Influx of Drugs and Human Trafficking

One of the most pressing issues associated with a porous border is the influx of illicit drugs.

The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) has consistently reported that a significant portion of drugs, including fentanyl, heroin, and methamphetamine, enter the United States through the southern border.

These substances, often trafficked by powerful and violent drug cartels, contribute to the ongoing opioid crisis and have devastating effects on American communities.

In addition to drug trafficking, human trafficking remains a severe problem. Vulnerable migrants, particularly women and children, are often exploited by traffickers who promise them safe passage into the United States.

Who do you think would win the Presidency?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from LifeZette, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Many fall victim to forced labor, sexual exploitation, and other forms of modern slavery. The National Human Trafficking Hotline has documented thousands of cases annually, underscoring the human cost of inadequate border security.

Violent Crime and National Security

The correlation between a weak border and violent crime is another significant concern.

While the majority of migrants are seeking better lives and escaping dire conditions in their home countries, there are instances where individuals with criminal backgrounds exploit gaps in border security.

The influx of migrants has, at times, overwhelmed the ability of law enforcement agencies to conduct thorough background checks, potentially allowing dangerous individuals to slip through the cracks.

Moreover, the presence of drug cartels and human trafficking networks at the border contributes to an environment of violence and lawlessness.

Border communities often bear the brunt of this violence, with reports of kidnappings, murders, and other crimes linked to cartel activity. The overall impact on national security is profound, as these criminal organizations grow increasingly sophisticated and entrenched.

Trump’s Strong Border Policy

Former President Donald Trump’s administration took a markedly different approach to border security.

Central to Trump’s policy was the construction of a physical barrier, commonly referred to as the border wall. Trump argued that a strong, fortified border was essential to preventing illegal immigration, drug trafficking, and crime.

His administration oversaw the construction of approximately 450 miles of new and replacement barriers along the southern border.

Supporters of Trump’s border policy argue that the wall serves as a critical deterrent to illegal crossings and enhances the ability of border patrol agents to monitor and control the border more effectively. They contend that a strong border infrastructure, coupled with strict immigration enforcement, is vital to maintaining national security and upholding the rule of law.

The Case for a “Big Beautiful Gate”

While the construction of a physical barrier is a contentious issue, there is a broader conversation to be had about legal immigration and the need for a more welcoming, efficient process for those seeking to enter the United States lawfully. President Trump’s messaging on border policy would be best served to focus less on the wall and more on a “big beautiful gate”—a metaphor for a robust legal immigration system that balances security with compassion.

The idea of a “big beautiful gate” suggests that the U.S. can and should maintain strong border security while also providing a clear, accessible pathway for legal immigration.

This approach acknowledges the legitimate aspirations of individuals and families seeking a better life while ensuring that those entering the country do so through proper channels.

A well-regulated legal immigration system can help to deter illegal crossings by offering a viable alternative, reducing the burden on border security, and addressing labor market needs.

Balancing Security and Compassion

To achieve this balance, policymakers must prioritize both enforcement and reform.

Strengthening border security through a combination of physical barriers, advanced technology, and increased personnel is essential.

However, this must be complemented by comprehensive immigration reform that streamlines the legal immigration process, reduces bureaucratic obstacles, and addresses the root causes of migration, such as violence, poverty, and political instability in migrants’ home countries.

Moreover, a focus on humanitarian policies that protect vulnerable populations, particularly unaccompanied minors and asylum seekers, is crucial.

This includes expanding resources for immigration courts to expedite cases and ensure fair, timely adjudication, as well as increasing support for border communities to manage the influx of migrants humanely.

The debate over the U.S. southern border is complex, with significant implications for national security, public safety, and humanitarian concerns.

While the Biden administration’s policies have aimed to create a more compassionate approach, they have also faced criticism for contributing to a surge in illegal immigration and associated challenges and all of the illegal drugs, human trafficking and potential terrorists that are coming into our country.

Conversely, former President Trump’s emphasis on a strong border, symbolized by the construction of a wall, underscores the importance of security and enforcement.

Ultimately, the solution lies in finding a middle ground that integrates the strengths of both approaches.

By envisioning a “big beautiful gate” alongside a secure border, the U.S. can create a system that welcomes legal immigrants while safeguarding national interests.

This dual approach not only enhances security but also honors America’s legacy as a nation of immigrants, providing hope and opportunity to those who seek a better life within its borders.