WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Rep. Lateefah Simon reportedly plans to introduce legislation offering relief to some illegal aliens with final removal orders.
  • Qualifying removal orders would expire after 10 years, creating a pathway for individuals without criminal convictions to pursue green cards.
  • Roughly 1.6 million illegal aliens in the United States have received final orders of removal.
  • Conservative commentators argued the proposal would reward people who remained after their immigration appeals were exhausted.

House Democrats are reportedly preparing legislation that would offer relief to some illegal aliens who already have final orders of removal. The proposal would also establish a pathway for qualifying individuals to obtain legal permanent residency.

ABC reported that the legislation, called the “Protect Our Neighbors Act,” will be introduced by California Democrat Rep. Lateefah Simon of CA-12. The reported plan targets illegal aliens who have final removal orders but have not been convicted of a crime.

Under the proposal, a final order of removal would expire 10 years after it was issued if the individual remained in the United States without a criminal conviction. That expiration would clear the way for the person to pursue a green card.

Final orders of removal represent deportation orders issued after the appeals process has been exhausted, according to the description of the proposal shared by Fox News reporter Bill Melugin. The legislation would therefore apply to people whose legal efforts to remain in the country have already ended.

Gun Laws Have Changed! Protect yourself by knowing where you can and cannot carry your firearm, so you can travel with confidence.

ABC journalist Juhi Doshi reported that Simon’s legislation was inspired by the case of Harjit Kaur. Kaur was described as a 73 year old grandmother who lived in the San Francisco Bay Area for three decades before she was deported to India.

Doshi said the bill would provide relief to certain immigrants with final removal orders and no criminal record. It would then create a route for those individuals to obtain legal permanent residency despite the existing deportation orders.

The potential reach of the proposal is substantial. Roughly 1.6 million illegal aliens living in the United States have received final orders of removal.

Melugin said former Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons testified before Congress in February that more than 1.6 million illegal aliens with deportation orders were in the United States. The reported legislation would place a 10 year expiration date on qualifying orders.

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from LifeZette, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

The proposal surfaced as Hakeem Jeffries was also pledging immigration action if Democrats regain control of the House. Jeffries said Democrats would move quickly to advance the Dream and Promise Act during the next Congress.

“We are going to move the Dream and Promise Act in the next Congress, early in the next Congress.” Jeffries made that pledge while describing ICE as “totally out of control” and demanding that the agency’s $75 billion in funding be redirected.

Conservative commentators sharply criticized the new legislation and its treatment of final removal orders. Ryan James Girdusky argued that people subject to those orders should not receive legal permanent residence after losing their immigration cases.

“If they have final orders of removal, it means they applied for asylum and their claims were found fraudulent and they have no legal right to be here.” Girdusky compared the proposed relief to losing a lawsuit and still expecting to receive money.

Nick Sortor also blasted the measure, arguing that an illegal alien could avoid ICE for 10 years and then receive a pathway to a green card. He urged the Trump administration not to retreat from deportations.

The National Immigration Center for Enforcement delivered a shorter verdict on the reported Democratic priority. “Amnesty first, affordability last.”

Scott Mechkowski described the measure as effectively giving deportation orders an expiration date. His post argued that someone could lose appeals, remain in the country for 10 years without a criminal conviction, and then receive an opportunity to seek a green card.

Mechkowski also claimed that funding and administrative delays would not count against the proposed clock. He argued that the legislation would reward people who remained after a judge ordered their removal while offering nothing to those who complied and left.

The reported bill would convert time spent remaining in the United States under a final removal order into potential eligibility for permanent legal status. For critics, that is the central problem: an exhausted legal process would no longer necessarily produce an enduring removal order.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LifeZette. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.