WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Senate Republicans moved to advance about two dozen federal judicial nominees during the lame duck session.
  • Cory Booker accused Republicans of pursuing nominations for short term political gain and creating a cloud over the nominees.
  • Ted Cruz cited 22 judges advanced by Senate Democrats during the 2024 lame duck session.
  • Cruz argued that judicial nominations and Senate confirmation votes are part of the constitutional system.

Senate Democrats opened the lame duck session with infighting over who would serve as majority leader in the incoming Congress, while Senate Republicans turned their attention to the federal bench. With power still in hand, Republicans moved to advance about two dozen federal judicial nominees.

As of Tuesday, 11 judicial and executive nominees had advanced from the Senate Judiciary Committee. Another seven were scheduled for debate during a Wednesday committee hearing.

Toward the end of that hearing, Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey delivered a dramatic lecture aimed at Republicans. Booker, who is rumored to be considering a 2028 presidential run, accused the GOP of pursuing nominations for “short-term political gain at the cost of the enduring strength of our institutions.”

Booker then turned his attention to the nominees and their families. He suggested the Republican handling of the process would leave a “cloud” hanging over their judicial records.

Gun Laws Have Changed! Protect yourself by knowing where you can and cannot carry your firearm, so you can travel with confidence.

“It's disappointing to me. I've watched time and time again the erosion of this institution and the erosion of this committee, and this is clearly one of them,” Booker said.

He continued: “God bless each and every one of you, and your families that are behind you. Thank you for your years and careers of service. I'm sorry that you're going to be appointed to the bench under the cloud that's been created by this committee.”

Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas was not impressed with the performance. Cruz, who is also rumored to be exploring a 2028 presidential bid, responded by accusing Booker and Senate Democrats of glaring hypocrisy.

“You know, there's an old adage that hypocrisy is the tribute that vice pays to virtue,” Cruz said.

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from LifeZette, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Cruz compared Booker’s indignation to Captain Renault in “Casablanca,” describing the New Jersey senator as shocked by the discovery that a Republican Senate would confirm judges nominated by a Republican president during a lame duck session. His point was simple: Democrats had recently done precisely what Booker was now condemning.

“You know, you don't need a particularly long memory to recognize the hypocrisy in what Sen. Booker said,” Cruz said.

Cruz pointed directly to the 2024 lame duck session, when Joseph Robinette Biden was in the White House. He said voters that year elected a Republican president, a Republican Senate, and a Republican House while repudiating the Democrat Party.

According to Cruz, Senate Democrats responded to that defeat by pushing through 22 federal judges in November and December before leaving. That record made Booker’s latest lecture especially rich.

“And what did the same Senate Democrats who just gave us sanctimonious speeches do? They rammed through 22 federal judges in November and December before leaving,” Cruz said.

Cruz also highlighted Booker’s claim that the dispute was not about the political left or right. Booker had argued that senators needed to stand up for the institution, but Cruz noted that Booker and every other Democrat on the committee had, he believed, voted for all 22 judges advanced in 2024.

“By the way, my friend from New Jersey also said, "This is not a left or right thing. We need to stand up." Sen. Booker and every other Democrat on this committee, I believe, voted for all 22 of those judges,” Cruz said.

Cruz framed those confirmations as the normal operation of the constitutional system, not an institutional scandal. Presidents nominate judges, he said, while the Senate provides its advice and consent.

“That is called the operation of democracy, and that is called our constitutional system in which presidents appoint, or nominate, judges and the Senate provides advice and consent,” Cruz said.

The exchange added another chapter to the history of sparring between Cruz and Booker during judicial confirmation hearings. Both senators have become known over the years for clashing in that setting.

With both men rumored to have presidential ambitions for 2028, the committee confrontation could offer a preview of another political collision if each eventually runs and secures his party’s nomination. For now, Cruz used Democrats’ own recent conduct to puncture Booker’s theatrical complaint.

Booker tried to cast the Republican confirmation effort as an erosion of the Senate Judiciary Committee and a stain on the nominees. Cruz answered with the inconvenient record of 22 judges advanced by Democrats during the 2024 lame duck session, cutting the performance down to size.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LifeZette. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.