WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Trump accused outgoing Sen. John Cornyn of doing a “tremendous disservice” by blocking T. Elliot Gaiser’s nomination for a Dallas judicial seat.
- Cornyn refused to return the blue slip, citing insufficient consultation, limited Texas connections, no trial court experience and inadequate vetting.
- Ted Cruz called Cornyn’s decision “really frustrating” and said the blocked nomination would leave the seat vacant.
- Cruz said Republicans were racing to confirm judges before Democrats take control of the Senate in January.
President Donald Trump sharply criticized outgoing Texas Sen. John Cornyn for blocking T. Elliot Gaiser, the president’s choice for a judicial seat in Dallas. Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America” that Cornyn was doing a “tremendous disservice” by stopping the nomination.
“We're going to have a radical left lunatic get in there, and we don't want that,” Trump said. His warning came as Republicans face a narrowing window to confirm judicial nominees before Democrats take control of the Senate in January.
Cornyn told The Associated Press that he has no intention of returning the blue slip for Gaiser, a senior lawyer at the Department of Justice. Gaiser was nominated by Trump to serve on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas.
The blue slip tradition allows senators from a nominee’s home state to weigh in on judicial selections. Returning the slip signals approval for the nomination to move ahead, while withholding it effectively blocks the process.
MORE NEWS: Los Angeles Restaurant Apocalypse Explodes as Hundreds Close and City Policies Take the Blame
Trump said he had heard strong reviews of Gaiser and accused Cornyn of allowing personal feelings to interfere. “Everybody tells me he's outstanding, and he's being held up by John Cornyn because John Cornyn's feelings were hurt,” the president said.
Trump endorsed Cornyn’s challenger, Ken Paxton, in the Texas Republican Senate primary. The president said Cornyn would have lost by a wide margin and described Gaiser as “fantastic.”
Cornyn responded later Saturday with a post on X that questioned the timing of the nomination. “If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone?” Cornyn wrote.
Cornyn said the seat has been vacant since 2025 and argued that Gaiser was nominated without consultation. He described Gaiser as a non Texan with little connection to the state, no trial court experience, and insufficient vetting for a lifetime appointment.
The Texas senator also invoked the Senate’s constitutional responsibility to provide advice and consent. Cornyn said that responsibility could not be fulfilled without consultation between the White House and senators.
If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone? The seat has been vacant since 2025. Then, without any consultation, he nominates a non-Texan with little connection to the Lone Star State, with no trial court experience, and who has not been appropriately vetted for a lifetime job. The Senate has a constitutional responsibility to provide "advise and consent," which is impossible without consultation.
— Senator John Cornyn (@JohnCornyn) November 21, 2026
Still, Cornyn said he wanted to work with Trump to fill the vacancy while Republicans retained their Senate majority. He said he had forwarded another candidate who received strong ratings from a bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee organized by Cornyn and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz.
According to Cornyn, that candidate has been interviewed by White House Counsel and only needs an FBI background check. “Back to you, Mr. President. Time is of the essence,” Cornyn wrote.
Cruz called Cornyn’s decision “really frustrating” and described confronting him on the Senate floor. Cruz said he asked Cornyn to allow the nomination to proceed and urged him to meet with Gaiser, but Cornyn refused.
Cruz said he warned Cornyn that blocking Gaiser would hand the judicial seat to Democrats. According to Cruz, Cornyn became angry during their discussion, began screaming and cursed at him.
The Texas senator said Republicans had agreed after their midterm losses to confirm as many judges as possible before the end of the year. Cruz said he expects Democrats to block all judicial confirmations after they enter the Senate majority in January.
Texas had two judicial vacancies, according to Cruz, including one in Austin that was moving forward and expected to be filled by year’s end. He said there was not enough time to process a completely new nominee for the Dallas opening because the paperwork and FBI background check would take weeks.
The White House therefore proposed Gaiser, who already served as a senior Department of Justice lawyer. Cruz said Gaiser previously clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., served as a state solicitor general arguing before the Supreme Court, and led the Office of Legal Counsel.
Cruz said he interviewed Gaiser and found him “incredibly principled, smart, capable, ready.” He said Cornyn’s refusal to return the blue slip means the Dallas seat will remain vacant and, in his view, will ultimately go to Democrats.
The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LifeZette. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.