WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Vance says deportations could lower housing prices and rents.
  • He argues fewer illegal workers could raise middle-class wages.
  • Vance says supply and demand supports his economic case.
  • Coglianese called the situation “an amazing thing.”

JD Vance argued that removing illegal immigrants from the United States would ease pressure on housing, jobs and public safety, saying basic supply-and-demand principles support the idea that deportations could lower rents and home prices while increasing wages for American workers.

Vance said immigration enforcement would not solve every problem facing the country, but he argued that several major economic and public safety concerns would improve if fewer illegal immigrants were competing with Americans for limited resources.

"A lot of the problems that exist in American society would be solved-not all of them, but just by deporting illegal aliens. So lower housing prices, lower rents, lower violent crime statistics," Vance said.

He also connected immigration enforcement to falling crime rates, arguing that law enforcement support and the removal of violent offenders have both contributed to lower murder rates.

Gun Laws Have Changed! Protect yourself by knowing where you can and cannot carry your firearm, so you can travel with confidence.

"One of the reasons why we have a historically low murder rate is, of course, because we've been supporting law enforcement, but also because we've gotten a lot of violent criminals out of the United States of America," Vance said.

Vance then recalled a previous interview in which he said the economic connection between immigration and housing costs had been challenged.

"But I remember that interview, Vince, because what what Lula said is, well, there's no economic evidence to support that deporting a lot of people who are competing against Americans for homes would lower the cost of homes," Vance said.

He rejected that argument, saying the effect should be apparent from basic economics.

Should members of Congress have term limits?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from LifeZette, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

"I'm like, well, it's basic supply and demand," Vance said.

Vance said there is also economic analysis supporting his position, pointing to research in both England and the United States.

"Second of all, there actually was a lot of economic evidence, both in England and in the United States," Vance said.

He specifically cited an analysis by the Federal Reserve that he said examined the impact of reducing the number of people competing for housing.

"Like our own Federal Reserve had done an economic analysis and said, "Well, if you get rid of all these people who are competing against Americans for homes, then it's going to cause home prices to go down," Vance said.

Vance extended the same argument to the labor market, saying deportations would reduce competition for jobs and put upward pressure on wages.

"Also, by the way, if you deport a lot of people who are competing against Americans for jobs, it's going to raise wages for middle-class Americans," Vance said.

He said both outcomes follow directly from supply-and-demand principles.

"Both of those things are obviously a consequence of supply and demand, but it's interesting to me," Vance said.

Vance then criticized political leaders who, in his view, fail to recognize the connection between large increases in population and higher housing demand.

"I'm always fascinated by just the mindset and the psychology of the people who lord over us, and the fact that you don't see an association between dropping a million illegal aliens into a state and the upward pressure that would put on home prices," Vance said.

He argued that the relationship should be obvious to anyone looking at the economics involved.

"You have to be economically blind to not see that, unfortunately, that's true of a lot of our leadership," Vance said.

Vince Coglianese agreed with Vance’s broader point and expressed disbelief that the economic argument remains controversial.

"Yeah, that's for sure. It's just an amazing thing," Coglianese said.

WATCH:

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LifeZette. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.