CBS News faced heavy criticism following Sunday’s episode of 60 Minutes, which aired segments questioning free speech protections and misrepresenting the employment status of individuals impacted by USAID cuts.

The controversy began earlier in the day when Face the Nation host Margaret Brennan claimed that “weaponized free speech” was responsible for the Holocaust.

Her statement drew immediate backlash, as critics pointed out that Nazi Germany was defined by censorship and state-controlled propaganda rather than an excess of free speech.

NEW: Secretary of State Marco Rubio smacks down CBS News’ Margaret Brennan after she bizarrely claimed the Holocaust happened because of too much free speech.

Brennan verbally struggled as she tried relating JD Vance’s comments on free speech to Nazis.

Brennan: “[Vance] was… pic.twitter.com/9n1TdcRy1i

— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) February 16, 2025

Later that evening, 60 Minutes aired a segment highlighting Germany’s strict speech laws, which criminalize certain types of online content under the pretense of combating misinformation and extremism.

This Could Be the Most Important Video Gun Owners Watch All Year

The report praised these restrictions, featuring interviews with figures like Josephine Ballon, CEO of the organization HateAid.

During the segment, Ballon argued that free speech should have “boundaries” to prevent certain individuals from dominating discussions.

“Free speech needs boundaries, and in the case of Germany, these boundaries are part of our constitution. Without boundaries, a very small group of people can rely on endless freedom to say anything that they want, while everyone else is scared and intimidated,” Ballon said.

The interviewer responded, “And your fear is that if people are freely attacked online that they’ll withdraw from the discussion.”

Ballon claimed this was already happening, stating, “Already half of the internet users in Germany are afraid to express their political opinions and they rarely participate in public debates online anymore.”

“Free speech needs boundaries… Without boundaries, a very small group of people can rely on endless freedom to say anything that they want, while everyone else is scared and intimidated,” says Josephine Ballon, CEO of HateAid. https://t.co/YjlBa7YJ3s pic.twitter.com/xqI88oiiO2

— 60 Minutes (@60Minutes) February 17, 2025

Critics of the segment pointed out that Germany’s restrictive laws, which criminalize speech deemed “false” or “dangerous” by the government, contribute to the very fear Ballon described.

The report also did not define what constituted “online violence”, raising concerns about how broadly the term could be applied.

In another segment of the same 60 Minutes episode, the program aired a report on layoffs at the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), portraying dismissed workers as victims of the Biden-Harris administration’s decision to halt foreign aid distribution.

The segment featured an interview with Kristina Drye, who described the impact of the job losses.

“People are really scared. I think that, you know, twelve days ago, people knew where their next paycheck was coming from. They knew how they were going to pay for their kids’ daycare, their medical bills, and then, all gone overnight,” Drye said.

The interviewer added in a voiceover, “All gone overnight for Kristina Drye and Adam Dubard, fired this month in the chaotic shutdown of foreign aid distribution by the U.S. Agency for International Development, USAID. More than 8,000 USAID employees were sent home by the administration.”

“Twelve days ago, people knew where their next paycheck was coming from. They knew how they were going to pay for their kids’ daycare, their medical bills. And then, all gone overnight,” says Kristina Drye, who was fired in the USAID shutdown. https://t.co/cysOqteb8p pic.twitter.com/bUcOAnhMjs

— 60 Minutes (@60Minutes) February 17, 2025

However, it was later revealed that Drye and Dubard were not full-time USAID employees but contracted consultants.

Drye, in particular, worked as a speechwriter for USAID Administrator Samantha Power, a Biden appointee.

60 Minutes pulled in 2 comms consultants who were never actual employees of USAID and presented them as though they were longtime employees who were fired for lack of “loyalty.” https://t.co/dxinUlR3T0 pic.twitter.com/nGdEp65DVL

— Eli Steinberg (@HaMeturgeman) February 17, 2025

The misrepresentation drew significant criticism, as 60 Minutes had just promoted Germany’s speech restrictions under the justification of preventing misinformation—only to mislead its own viewers within the same broadcast.

The controversy surrounding 60 Minutes and CBS News added to ongoing concerns about the network’s credibility, as both segments drew sharp rebukes from viewers and media watchdogs.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LifeZette. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.