The same people who are all for “choice” in killing babies are not for choice when it comes to education. That’s crazy. Benjamin Toma, Republican Majority Leader of the Arizona House, explains the issue.
Give me one good argument against school choice policies like the one in Arizona? Is there a single one?
— Steven Crowder (@scrowder) July 1, 2022
Toma: The Arizona Legislature recently passed the most expansive school choice law in the nation, opening our Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) eligibility to all school-age children without restriction. As majority leader in the Arizona House of Representatives, it was my privilege to sponsor the legislation and guide it to the finish line, delivering educational freedom to more than 1.1 million students.
I’m proud to continue the Arizona tradition of leading on school choice. In 1997 we were the first state with a tax credit scholarship program and in 2011 we passed the nation’s first ESA law, which has slowly expanded to cover about a quarter of our students.
We are now the first state with a truly universal ESA program. Essentially, parents who apply for an ESA may direct about $7,000 to expenses like private school tuition, homeschooling expenses, educational therapies, and tutoring in exchange for not attending a public school or receiving a tuition tax credit scholarship.
While many scoffed at the notion that the Arizona Legislature could pass a universal ESA with single-vote Republican advantages in both chambers, I sensed the time was right for bold choices on education. West Virginia passed a massive ESA expansion last year. Gov. Kim Reynolds of Iowa raised eyebrows when she successfully supported primary defeats of eight incumbent Republicans who opposed her school choice measure. Lawmakers are taking notice. It’s time to put school choice laws on the board of truth.
Despite the pandemic and culture wars boosting interest in school choice, victories here are not a fait accompli – even in red states. Conservatives must be focused yet flexible to achieve progress.
Public pressure alone wasn’t enough to pass ESAs in Arizona. Well-meaning Republicans care about their local public schools and sympathize with their opposition. Rural lawmakers worry about how it impacts their districts. Friday night lights is a real thing.
You can call them RINO’s or you can try to respond to their concerns. In Arizona, we showed lawmakers the data: though more than 250,000 students are currently eligible, just 11,000 or so use an ESA after a decade of existence. In areas with great public schools, there are often few ESA users.
The truth is ESAs won’t cripple public schools. But we think it will make them better. After years of unlimited district open enrollment and the highest percentage of students in charter schools in the nation, choosing your child’s school – instead of being directed by the government – is the norm here. The results: Arizona schools lead the nation in academic growth for both poor and nonpoor students per the Stanford Opportunity Project.
We invested more than $1 billion in our school finance formula this year, most of which was to show holdouts that we weren’t giving up on our public schools and were willing to deal. We were able to make that investment knowing it was buying radical reform, not because we were caving to cries from the Left about school funding. We know those demands are eternal. We remain focused on improving outcomes and making choice a reality for all students.